Bulls Loving The "Heads I Win, Tails I Win" Market

Authored by Lance Roberts via RealInvestmentAdvice.com,

It was a close call, but Santa finally delivered with a strong rally this past week, pushing the markets to all-time highs. Interestingly, despite the “Blue Sweep” of the Georgia elections, the markets quickly turned from worrying that such would be harmful to the markets. Markets quickly dismissed concerns of higher taxes by justifying it with more stimulus and more significant deficits. In other words, “buy everything in sight.”

As I tweeted out on Tuesday:

While I do jest a bit, market participants quickly justify paying continually higher prices for investments.

Why not? Mainly when it’s a “Heads I win, Tails I win” market.

As I noted last week, it certainly seems as if there is no “risk” in investing. As markets continue to rise, investors are becoming increasingly confident. But therein lies the risk as confidence breeds complacency. 

In the short-term, the bullish trends remain intact. After a month-long choppy process, the S&P 500 finally set a new all-time high. The good news is that short-term MACD signals and money flows are favorable, suggesting prices could rise higher in the short-term.

However, notice that while the MACD, and money flow, are positive, the market remains significantly overbought short-term. Such suggests that while markets could rise, it could be somewhat limited return relative to the risk.

On a longer-term basis, the markets remain grossly extended from long-term means. The only other times we have seen these extensions in recent years often resulted in the loss of short-term gains rather quickly.

A correction within the next 2-months would not be surprising given the deviations from long-term means. However, such does not preclude more upside first.

The Risk Of The Bullish View

As we noted last week:

“Currently, every single analyst has the same story going into 2021.

  • Prepare for an economic boom.

  • Interest rates will rise.

  • Inflation is coming back.

  • The stock market is going to 4100-4500

  • Small-caps are the new ‘new trade.’”

You get the idea. Everyone is incredibly “bullish” about the coming year with hopes of more stimulus, infrastructure spending, and a vaccine.

Somehow, despite millions of people still unemployed, the economy has just shifted into a “Golden Age” not seen since the 1950s.

However, therein lies the problem.

We Can’t Go Back

There have been two previous periods in history that have had the necessary ingredients to support a rising trend of interest rates, inflation, and economic growth over an extended period.

The first was during the previous century’s turn as the country became more accessible via railroads and automobiles. Production ramped up for World War I, and America began shifting from an agricultural to an industrial economy. (Read more on why this isn’t the “Roaring 20s.”

The second period was post-World War II. The war left America the “last man standing” after France, England, Russia, Germany, Poland, Japan, and others were devastated. It was here that America found its most substantial run of economic growth in its history as the “boys of war” returned home to start rebuilding the countries that they had just destroyed.

The U.S. is no longer the manufacturing powerhouse it once was, and globalization has sent jobs to the cheapest labor sources. Technological advances continue to reduce the need for human labor and suppress wages as productivity increases. Today, the number of workers between the ages of 16 and 54 participating in the labor force is near the lowest level relative to that age group since the late 70s.

There is also a structural and demographic problem that continues to drag on economic growth as nearly 1/4th of the American population is now dependent on some form of governmental assistance. These issues are only going to worsen due to long-term demographic trends, not only domestically but globally.

In other words, the ingredients required for sustained levels of more robust economic growth and prosperity are not available.

Trending In The Wrong Direction

As shown below, there is a correlation between the three major components of economic growth: inflation, interest rates, and wage growth.

Interest rates are not only a function of the investment market, but rather the level of “demand” for capital in the economy. When the economy is expanding organically, the demand for capital rises as a business increases production to meet rising demand. Increased production leads to higher wages, which in turn fosters more aggregate demand. As consumption increases, so does producers’ ability to charge higher prices (inflation) and for lenders to increase borrowing costs. (Currently, we do not have the type of inflation that leads to more robust economic growth, just inflation in the costs of living that saps consumer spending – Rent, Insurance, Health Care)

Note that “production” is the key to economic growth. Consumption that is dependent solely on increases in debt, or stimulus, has a negative impact on growth.

The chart above is a bit busy. If we combine the individual subcomponents into a composite index, the correlation with interest rates becomes clearer.

Blue Plans Won’t Lead To Growth.

Currently, investors hope that with a “Blue Wave,” more stimulus, increased deficits, and infrastructure spending is soon on their way. Goldman Sachs just upgraded their estimate of GDP growth based on the expectation of another $750 billion stimulus bill.

The surge in deficit spending, combined with the pick up in short-term demand for construction and manufacturing processes, will give the appearance of economic growth. Such will likely get both the Federal Reserve and the “bond bears” on the wrong side of the trade.

The impacts of these “one-off” inputs into the economy will fade rather quickly after implementation as organic productivity fails to increase. While many always hope these programs will lead to an ongoing economic expansion, a look at the last 40 years of fiscal and monetary policy suggests it won’t.


Because you can’t create economic growth when financed by deficit spending, credit, and a reduction in savings.

You can create the “illusion” of growth in the short-term, but the surge in debt reduces both productive investments and the output from the economy. As the economy slows, wages fall, forcing consumers to take on more leverage and decrease their savings rate. As a result, of the increased leverage, more of their income is needed to service the debt, which requires them to take on more debt.

While more stimulus and infrastructure spending may spur the economy and markets initially, the payback tends to be severe. Such is why we keep ending up at this point, demanding more spending to fix the last drawdown. 

Wash. Rinse. Repeat.

Is The Reflation Trade Over?

The trade du jour has been to buy stocks that benefit the most from inflation. Energy and materials have been the hottest sectors over the last few weeks, and bitcoin is on fire. Conversely, utilities and REITs have suffered as higher interest rates tend to accompany inflationary expectations.

As such, the graph below is essential for stock investors to follow. Yes, we know it is TIP bonds, but it accurately quantifies the inflationary sentiment driving stocks.

The graph compares 2-year, and 10-year implied inflation levels. By comparing TIP yields to nominal Treasury yields, we extract the breakeven, or implied, inflation rate that makes investors indifferent between the two securities. As shown, short term expectations have risen from nearly -1% in April to 2.25% today. Short term expectations are at the highest level since 2013. 10-year inflation expectations are less volatile but have risen sharply.

The genius of the graph is the interaction of inflation expectations to the spread between the two. Short term inflation expectations tend to be lower than long term expectations. However, when they reach or exceed long-term expectations, they tend to peak and reverse sharply. The dotted lines highlight the seven times in the last 12 years this has occurred.

The bulls argue this time is different and inflation is a real threat, unlike the past. The bears rely on the past relationship and forecast a rapid decline in inflation expectations.

The eagles, ourselves included, have the luxury of watching the data and adjusting our stance as we see how the two rates react to the curve inversion.